Check out the most popular Home Insurance agencies & companies in Butler County, PA & compare the best quotes from them.

Get Quotes From The Best & Compare

Top Home Insurance Companies in Butler County, PA

Home Insurance Company A.M. Best Financial Strength Rating Homeowners Insurance Market share
Allstate A+ 13.33%
State Farm A 9%
Liberty Mutual A 8.33%
Nationwide A+ 7.7%
Travelers A++ 6.47%

Top Liberty Mutual Home Insurance Agents in Butler County, PA

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Deborah Youngblood 15 Stadium Dr
44512
(330) 726-8245
Liem Huynh 996 N MAIN ST LOWER LEVEL
15601
724-834-0500
Jamie Reeves 248 NEW CASTLE ROAD
16001
724-283-2423
David Valdix 120 N 5th St
15701
(724) 349-7952
Kathi Donnelly 2242 DARLINGTON RD CHIPPEWA
15010
724-843-4830
Matt Olson 284 N Market St
44413-2132
(330) 426-9581
Pamela Gaglia Lutcf Aai Ais Acs 1269 WASHINGTON PIKE
15017
(412) 221-7010
Travis Thierry 11 Maplewood St Pittsburgh
15223
Vu Nguyen 485 Mansfield Ave Pittsburgh
15205
Cindy Baxter 419 N Main St
16025-3205
724-445-3550

Top State Farm Home Insurance Agents in Butler County, PA

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Bobby Kelly 1331 Freeport Rd Ste 207
www.bobbykelly.net 15024-1233
724-274-5445
Joe Tamm 5121 BRIGHTWOOD RD
www.joetamm.com 15102
412-835-4747
Joe Seed 121 WEST PIKE ST
www.joeseed.com 15317
724-745-1600
Lane Sander CARNEGIE OFFICE PARK BLDG TWO 600 N BELL AVE STE 120
www.lanesander.com 15106
412-200-2018
Joe Veiga 311 MAIN ST
www.joeveigainsurance.com 15642
724-863-3420
Mary Sue Smith 314 N 4Th Street
www.marysuesmith.com 15697-1312
(724) 925-9040
Charlie Sangermano 121 N McKean St
16201-1567
724-543-FARM
Terry Fink 308 Main St Ford\u00a0City
www.askfink.com 16226
Larry De La Fuente 920 FORT DUQUESNE BLVD
15222
412-261-1842
Malia Hayward 220 W Venango St Ste 214
www.juneausf.com 16137
(724) 662-4200

Top Allstate Home Insurance Agents in Butler County, PA

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Larry Dumas Jr. 850 RIDGE AVE
15212
412-237-2020
Sebastian De Almenara 18 Village Park Drive
16127
Scott Boggs 20550 Route 19
16066
Jorge Bendeck 2455 RTE 286 S
15701
800-622-2020
Kirk Clark 2564 COLE ROAD
15090
412-238-8200
Catherine Peduto 221 Butler Rd
16201-1958
724-548-8180
Jamie Hayes 1509 FOURTH AVE
16226
724-763-9125
John Barber 800 CENTER MAIN ST
16214
814-226-8041
Rebecca Leau 101 W Pittsburgh St
15601
(724) 691-0202
Cooper-Bumpus Insurance Agency 892 W Liberty
44425
330-534-3004

Top Nationwide Home Insurance Agents in Butler County, PA

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Michael L Kahl 9026 Saint Simon Way
15237
(412) 364-7170
Russell Billapando 6066 William Flynn Hwy
15044
Griffin Insurance Agency Inc. 438 Walnut St
15143
(412) 741-9700
Pamela Stern & Associates Llc 120 TROPIANO LN
15642
724-392-4586
Bailey Agency Inc 9576 Perry Hwy Ste 201
15237-5508
412-367-0111
Fahey Insurance Agency Inc 8162 Market St Ste H
44512
(330) 953-2034
Michele Deery-Thomas Clu 7600 Market St
44512
(330) 726-8177
Michael L Fields Agency 3841 William Penn Highway
15146
(412) 317-5500
Michael D. Banks 9938 Route 322 Suite 1
16254-8986
(814) 226-8820
Charles Norton Jr Ste 1B 1295 Boardman Canfield Rd
44512-4024
330-758-8884

Top Travelers Home Insurance Agents in Butler County, PA

Homeowners Insurance Agents Agent Address Contact Details
Sam Boaz Real Estate & Insurance 239 W Pike Street
15317

Email:farmersagent341@aol.com
Owen Ins Group Inc 833 BOARDMAN CANFIELD RD STE 101
www.tomowenagency.com 44512
(330) 533-6500
Email:TOM@OWENINS.COM
Overton Insurance Agency Inc 7905 STATE ROUTE 45
44432
(740) 537-1282
Lane Ins Group Llc 4893 CAMPBELLS RUN RD
www.laneinsurancegroup.com 15205
412-787-7800
Email:mike@laneinsurancegroup.com
Kelbro Insurance Services Inc 230 CENTER RD
15146
412-373-9940
Email:kelbroins@gmail.com
Thompson & Story Agency Inc 672 E 2Nd St
44460
Peoples First Insurance 2009 Mackenzie Way Ste 320
16066
(412) 200-6418
Family Insurance Agency 2956 E State St
16148
(724) 346-1000
Select Insurance Resources Llc 1519 Mt Nebo Road
15143
Mcgregor Insurance Agency Inc 237A Broad St
www.insure-coverage.net 16242-1001
(814) 275-1166

Homeowners Insurance Comparison for the Cheapest Premiums in Butler County, PA

TravelersLiberty MutualState Farm
Median Home Value ($) 171,000201,000201,000
Construction year 199820031985
Home Coverage ($) $250000-$300000$250000-$300000$200000-$250000
Total Premium ($) $1155$1485$945

Butler County, PA Multi Policy Discounts by Home Insurance Companies

Home Insurance Company Multi Policy Discount (%)
Liberty Mutual upto 18%
Allstate upto 21%
Nationwide upto 9%
Travelers upto 11%